The Collection: Season 17

This was the tenth season released, on 20th December 2021 in the UK. It was reissued on 22nd January 2024 in standard packaging, with a shorter booklet.

Risen

Sources

All stories are taken from D3 copies of the original 2″ transmission masters, with credits rebuilt in true HD, colour-graded to match the original episodes. Some film inserts from City of Death showing the Jagaroth ship are included in HD.

UK Release History

VHSVHS ArtDVDDVD Art
Destiny of the Daleks4/7/94
7/9/01
Colin Howard26/11/07Lee Binding
City of Death8/4/91
8/5/01
Uncredited [Andrew Skilleter]
Uncredited [Black Sheep]
7/11/05Uncredited [Clayton Hickman]
The Creature from the Pit15/7/02Uncredited [Black Sheep]3/5/10Clayton Hickman
Nightmare of Eden1/99Uncredited [Black Sheep]2/4/12Lee Binding
The Horns of Nimon2/6/03Uncredited [Black Sheep]29/3/10Clayton Hickman
Shada6/7/92Photographic7/1/13
12/17
Clayton Hickman

Shada was released in numerous formats:

  • 1992: On VHS with linking narration by Tom Baker.
  • 2013: The VHS version, rebuilt in higher quality, and paired with More Than Thirty Years in the TARDIS as part of The Legacy Collection. The rebuild featured a slightly incorrect sequence in Part Three, detailed here.
  • 2017: An HD partly-animated movie, on DVD and BD, with the VHS version included as a bonus feature. The Part Three error was partly, but not completely, fixed, and this time the ‘VHS edition’ end credits were removed.

City of Death was reissued on VHS in 2001 with a revised cover. Destiny of the Daleks was included in a 2001 WH Smith exclusive Davros Collection VHS set. More images can be found here.

The Horns of Nimon‘s DVD release was part of the Myths and Legends box set. Destiny of the Daleks was the last of the Davros serials to be released on DVD, and came out alongside a Davros Collection set. All of the stories in Season 17, except Destiny and City, were released after a change in BBC logo, and as such featured reversable sleeves.

The restored episodes were issued as part of the Doctor Who DVD Files magazine (2009-14) across the following issues: 58: Destiny of the Daleks (Mar 23rd 2011); 37: City of Death (Jun 2nd 2010); 149: The Creature from the Pit (September 17th 2014); 134: Nightmare of Eden (Feb 19th 2014); and 139: The Horns of Nimon (Apr 30th 2014).

Summary

All episodes include their original mono soundtracks, along with two new optional 5.1s for Destiny of the Daleks. Both of these include a revised voice effect for Davros, but a second ‘enhanced’ one also includes additional music taken from Tristram Cary’s previous scores.

Optional CGI is also available for Destiny of the Daleks (by John Kelly, from the original DVD) and (and on Nightmare of Eden (new, by Chris Cassell and Justin T Lee). On the original Destiny DVD, Kelly had included some laser beam effects in an incorrect place – this was swiftly removed for overseas releases, and likewise are not present here.

Behind the sofa are:

  • Graeme Harper, June Hudson and Mat Irvine
  • Colin Baker and Matthew Waterhouse
  • Katy Manning and Nicola Bryant

Text commentaries have all been revised and updated from the originals by Martin Wiggins (Destiny of the Daleks, replacing Richard Molesworth’s originals), Martin Wiggins (City of Death), Nicholas Pegg (The Creature from the Pit and Nightmare of Eden) and Wiggins with Niall Boyce (The Horns of Nimon; Boyce wrote the originals solo). Wiggins, Pegg and Paul Scoones provided a brand new commentary for the six-part part-animated Shada. Previous releases had mostly not featured a text commentary, except for the 2013 iteration of the ‘VHS Shada‘, which had a commentary from Pegg that would naturally not synchronise with this longer edition.

Audio navigation is provided by Tom Baker.

Disc Layout

With the exception of the audio commentaries, titles are as they appear on the menu screen (and in the same order), with explanatory information in square brackets.

The disc layout was previewed in Doctor Who Magazine 571 (released 11 November 2021, cover date Winter 2021) with the features listed out of order, and with alternate titles.

Disc 1: Destiny of the Daleks (1:40:03)

Commentary by Lalla Ward, David Gooderson, Ken Grieve

Commentary #2 [1,4] with Tom Baker and Toby Hadoke [uncredited], new for BD

FormatLengthOriginal DVD Source & Notes
Making-of Documentary [Return to Skaro]HD44:11New
Behind the SofaHD31:16New
Directing Who [Ken Grieve]SD9:28Destiny of the Daleks
Terry Nation Documentary [Terror Nation]SD27:49Destiny of the Daleks
The Dalek TapesSD53:21Genesis of the Daleks
1979 Season Launch TrailerSD2:00Part of the trailers compilation on original DVD
2021 Blu-Ray Trailer [Risen]HD4:18New
Nationwide [02.04.79 – Radiophonic Workshop]SD8:45New
Blue Peter: Abseiling [17.05.79]SD8:13New
Blue Peter: Dalek [21.06.79, history of the Daleks plus a fan-made one]SD8:10New
BBC Trails & ContinuitiesSD8:043:45 compilation on DVD
Photo GalleryHD13:03New [SD 8:14 version on DVD]
Studio ClocksSD0:24Destiny of the Daleks [Easter Egg]

Total Disc Contents: 5:19:05

  • Prime Adverts (from the original DVD) moved to Season 18
  • Coming Soon: Beneath the Surface (from the original DVD) could move to Season 7 or 21 (it was not present on 9, the other obvious placing)

Disc 2: City of Death (1:39:38)

Commentary by Michael Hayes, Julian Glover, Tom Chadbon

Commentary #2 [1,4] with Tom Baker and Toby Hadoke [uncredited], new for BD

Commentary #3 with Lalla Ward & Catherine Schell, new for BD

Making-of Documentary [Paris in the Springtime]SD44:04City of Death
Behind the Sofa HD27:50New
Directing Who [Michael Hayes]SD8:27The Armageddon Factor SE
Design FeaturetteHD4:18New
Douglas Adams DocumentaryHD48:25New
Prehistoric Landscapes [model shots]HD2:27City of Death
Film TrimsHD9:59New
Visual Effects Footage [Chicken Wrangler]HD2:46City of Death
Studio Footage [Paris W12]SD20:05City of Death
Blue Peter [25.10.79 – K9]SD6:26New
BBC Trails & ContinuitySD4:52New, incorporating 0:18 easter egg on original DVD
Tom Baker & John Cleese SkitSD0:18City of Death [Easter Egg]
DVD Easter Egg [Douglas Adams 1985 interview]SD6:35City of Death [Easter Egg]
Photo GalleryHD13:048:40 SD version on original DVD
Coming Soon [The Creature from the Pit]SD0:41The Time Monster, Underworld, The Horns of Nimon

Total Disc Contents: 4:59:55

  • Eye on… Blatchford (13:00) and its easter egg (1:44), along with the easter egg spoof sales brochure (2:02) have all been removed
  • In the DWM preview, studio and location footage were erroneously listed under PDFs

Disc 3: The Creature from the Pit (1:36:39)

Commentary by Lalla Ward, Myra Frances, Christopher Barry, Mat Irvine.

FormatLengthOriginal DVD Source & Notes
Extended Part Three HD24:01New (4 seconds longer than transmitted version)
Making-of Featurette [Remembering…]HD14:51New
Visual Effects Featurette [Team Erato]SD14:48The Creature from the Pit
Behind the Sofa HD28:39New
Deleted SceneSD0:26The Creature from the Pit
Animal MagicSD2:38 The Creature from the Pit
Lalla Ward Remembers Season 17HD55:21New
BBC Choice Backstage [10.11.99 David Brierley]SD4:32New
BBC Trails & ContinuitiesSD2:56New
Photo GalleryHD8:034:51 SD version on The Creature from the Pit
Coming Soon [Nightmare of Eden]SD1:55The Dæmons

Total Disc Contents: 4:14:49

  • Coming Soon: The King’s Demons/Planet of Fire (from the original DVD) removed. It was not included on Season 20 and seems unlikely to be included on Season 21.
  • The Christopher Barry feature moved to Season 8

Disc 4: Nightmare of Eden (1:35:45)

Commentary by Lalla Ward, Peter Craze, Bob Baker, Colin Mapson, Joan Stribling, moderated by Toby Hadoke

FormatLengthOriginal DVD Source & Notes
Making-of Featurette [The Nightmare of Television Centre]HD13:24Nightmare of Eden
Behind the SofaHD24:46New
Bob Baker in ConversationHD1:08:26New
Going SoloHD7:46Nightmare of Eden
Nationwide [17.12.79 Doctor Who toys]SD3:25New
BBC Trails & ContinuitiesSD2:57New
Photo GalleryHD10:385:49 SD version on original DVD
The Doctor’s Strange LoveSD15:44Nightmare of Eden

Total Disc Contents: 4:02:51

  • Coming Soon: Ace Adventures (Dragonfire/The Happiness Patrol) (from the original DVD) was removed, and not included on either Season 24 or 25
  • Coming Soon: Myths and Legends (The Time Monster, Underworld and The Horns of Nimon) from The Space Museum/The Chase was not included, neither was it on Seasons 9 or 15
  • Ask Aspel moved to Disc 5

Disc 5: The Horns of Nimon (1:40:58)

Commentary by Lalla Ward, Janet Ellis, Graham Crowden, Anthony Read.

FormatLengthOriginal DVD Source & Notes
Behind the Sofa HD30:22New
Anthony Read Interview [Read the Writer]SD6:29The Horns of Nimon
Williams’ Era Documentary [A Matter of Time]SD60:03The Ribos Operation SE
The Doctor’s Composer [Part 2]SD18:05The Sun Makers
Music DemosSD2:58The Horns of Nimon
Swap Shop [29.12.79 – Lalla Ward]SD14:43New
Nationwide [07.02.80 – Lalla Ward]SD2:33New
Ask Aspel [15.07.80 – Lalla Ward]SD11:03Nightmare of Eden
The Panopticon Archive [Tom Baker]SD40:23New
Audio Archive [Genesis of the Daleks LP]Audio59:46Previously released on LP, cassette and CD
BBC Trails & ContinuitiesSD2:11New
Photo GalleryHD10:007:53 SD version on original DVD
Coming Soon [Shada] HD0:42New
DVD Easter Egg [Scottish Falsetto Sock Puppets sketch]SD1:20The Horns of Nimon [Easter Egg]

Total Disc Contents: 6:01:36

  • Who Peter: Part One (from the original DVD) moved to Season 26
  • Coming Soon: The Creature from the Pit (from the original DVD) moved to Disc 2

Disc 6: Shada (2:31:38)
(new 2021 six-part partially-animated version with optional 5.1)

FormatLengthOriginal DVD Source & Notes
Tom Baker IntroductionSD2:47Shada VHS
Making-of Documentary [Taken Out of Time]SD25:37Shada 2013 DVD, 2017 BD/DVD
Behind the SofaHD28:02New
Strike Strike StrikeSD27:47Shada 2013 DVD, 2017 BD/DVD
Now and ThenSD12:43Shada 2013 DVD, 2017 BD/DVD
Tom TalksHD41:25New
What’s on Wogan: K9 [31.05.80]SD2:24New
What’s on Wogan: Lalla Ward [28.06.80]SD2:45New
Clean Opening & Closing titlesHD2:25Shada BD (also on The Collection: Season 12 BD)
Photo Gallery [Original 1979 filming]HD9:43SD 4:47 version on Shada 2013 DVD, 2017 BD/DVD

Total Disc Contents: 5:04:29

  • The DWM preview mistakenly listed Trails and Continuity for Shada. Tom Talks was not mentioned.

Disc 7: Shada Bonuses

2017 audio commentary by Christopher Neame, Daniel Hill, Martin Geraghty and AnneMarie Walsh.

FormatLengthOriginal DVD Source & Notes
1992 VHS VersionSD1:49:34Shada VHS, 2013 DVD, 2017 Steelbook BD (1:48:56, removed VHS end credits)
Enhanced Movie Version [2017]HD2:18:22Shada 2017 BD, with enhanced animation from 2021 version
1979 Studio FootageSD2:28:29New
1979 Visual Efffects FootageHD4:00New
2017 Dialogue SessionsHD14:07Shada 2017 BD/DVD
2017 Deleted ScenesHD1:13Shada 2017 BD/DVD
2017 Model FilmingHD4:32Shada 2017 BD/DVD
2017 Animation Reference FootageHD2:38Shada 2017 BD/DVD
2017 Photo GalleryHD2:44Shada 2017 BD/DVD
Coming Soon [Season 18]HD1:50New, produced for YouTube to promote The Collection Season 18
Nationwide [24.10.80, with Tom Baker]SD4:32Logopolis

Total Disc Contents: 7:12:01

The Nationwide bonus sits much better on Season 18, so was presumably missed by accident and added here, as close as possible to its airdate.

  • The Big Finish Shada has been removed, perhaps for The Wilderness Years.
  • Coming Soon: The Reign of Terror (from the original DVD) expected to move to Season 1.
  • Being a Girl is generic about women in Doctor Who and is not presented here.
  • Production subtitles were present on the 2013 release of the VHS version, but were removed for both the 2017 and 2021 releases.
  • The 2017 studio footage feature was not included, possibly in error.

The 1992 Shada has been rebuilt several times over the years, creating slightly different versions of the sequence where the TARDIS team enter Skagra’s spacecraft in Part Three:

  1. After ‘What’s that carpet doing here?’ the 1992 cut across to the monitor on Skagra’s ship quicker than on the 2013 and 2017 version.
  2. After ‘Affirmative K9, affirmative!’ the 1992 and 2017 versions cut to the side angle of the ascent up to the ship and then the shot of the legs, followed by the shot of K9 ascending , while the 2013 version holds on Tom and co for the whole time.

…The 2021 version almost exactly matches the 2017 version, except that the legs are no longer cropped off at the top.

The DVD version of the 2017 release presented the studio scenes as de-interlaced in error, which effectively filmised them, and also presented it (as per the BD) with black bars forced onto the left and right to create a BD-compliant 16:9 video – meaning those watching on a 4:3 screen found black bars around all edges. DVDs of 4:3 material are usually encoded in true 4:3, leaving the TV to either add black bars or not, as needed.

PDF Material

Richard Bignell’s promo image on Twitter, summarising the PDF content

The original DVD releases contained Radio Times listings (except on City of Death), along with an RT article and poem (Destiny of the Daleks). City of Death contained the 1980 annual and The Horns of Nimon contained blueprints. The 2017 Shada release contained a large compilation of PDFs.

In the DWM preview, Douglas Adams’ Scriptwriter’s Guide (Disc 1) was not listed, and there was an erroneous listing for production documentation for the 2017 animated version of Shada, instead of 2017 storyboards. The preview also cited scripts for two 1992 VHS Tom Baker links, a confusing way of describing the two versions of the script (with and without annotations).